Rookies of the year...

[Baseball Guru]

Kinda a no brainer in both leagues and I doubt there will be much debate for either of these players...

NL: Pujos

AL: Suzuki

[loser69]

Is there any doubt in the National League?

[GiveHyzduashot]

For that matter loser, is there any doubt in the American League? The only guy within an earshot of Ichiro is Soriano.

[Yankee 21]

Soriano deserves it but Suzuki will get it! Technically Susuki isn't a rookie due to the fact he played in Japan's major league. Soriano's a real rookie! and I'm not just saying this cuz he's a Yankee. The kid deserves it. He's grown a lot this season ans deserves a pat on the back! He has gotten way more patient with his bat and has gotten real good in the field!

[Moose]

:drinkin: the mlb is something new to him. although he is like 28 you still just cant push him aside just because you want soriano to have it. and who knows, if soriano ends up over 300 with 25 homers and 40 steals he might get it. but that aint happening. you cant just take ichiro out of that catagory. but in the years to come dont be surprised if they start to because of the more japanese players that will arrive here. ichiro is a rookie, but the question is how much of one. he has played in the spot light in japan but has never been to the u.s. and it is new to him. a rookie means they are new to it. ichiro is new to the mlb. so you cant just throw him out of the catagory. but i still think soriano is gunna be something really good. lata...