Trade Dunn for Freddy G or Pettite?

[wehret]

Here is my squad...8 man h2h mixed league...pretty shallow...


C Kendall, Jason (C-Pit) CUtilBench Hou 7:05pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
1B Helton, Todd (1B-Col) 1BUtilBench NYM 9:05pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
2B Castillo, Luis (2B-Fla) 2BUtilBench @SD 10:05pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
3B Glaus, Troy (3B-Ana) 3BUtilBench - -/- - - - - - -
SS Rodriguez, Alex (SS-Tex) SSUtilBench - -/- - - - - - -
OF Berkman, Lance (CF, LF-Hou) OFUtilBench @Pit 7:05pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
OF Jones, Andruw (CF-Atl) OFUtilBench @LA 10:10pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
OF Ibanez, Raul (1B, LF, DH, RF-KC) 1BOFUtilBench @Min 8:05pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
Util Beltran, Carlos (CF-KC) OFUtilBench @Min 8:05pm EDT -/- - - - - - -
Bench Ordonez, Magglio (RF-CWS) OFUtilBench - -/- - - - - - -
Bench Dunn, Adam (LF, 1B, RF-Cin) 1BOFUtilBench - -/- - - - - - -


Pitchers Stats: Season | Last Month | Last Week | Today *
POS PLAYER EDIT OPP STATUS IP W SV K TB ERA WHIP
SP Perez, Odalis (SP-LA) SPPBench Atl 10:10pm EDT - - - - - - -
SP Hernandez, Runelvys (SP-KC) SPPBench @Min 8:05pm EDT - - - - - - -
SP Vazquez, Javier (SP-Mon) SPPBench @SF 10:15pm EDT - - - - - - -
RP Baez, Danys (SP, RP-Cle) SPRPPBench - - - - - - - -
RP Williams, Mike (RP-Pit) RPPBench Hou 7:05pm EDT - - - - - - -
P Politte, Cliff (RP-Tor) RPPBench - - - - - - - -
P Colon, Bartolo (SP-CWS) SPPBench - - - - - - - -
Bench Beckett, JoshDL (SP-Fla) SPPBenchDL @SD 10:05pm EDT - - - - - - -
Bench Millwood, Kevin (SP-Phi) SPPBench - - - - - - - -
Bench Alfonseca, Antonio (RP-ChC) RPPBench @Mil 8:05pm EDT - - - - - - -
DL Kim, Byung-HyunDL (RP, SP-Ari)

I don't like Garcia's or Pettite's WHIP #'s...but the wins are nice...and I have to bench Dunn half the time anyway...What do you think?

[edro500]

i say no
you can do better than those 2 guys for Dunn