Keeper Dilemas - Renteria or Brown

[shaemus287]

Alright, I get to keep 4 guys, and I need to decide by 7/31.
There are no $$ values, I just got to pick 4 guys.

In:
Halladay
Schmidt
Soriano

Bubble:
Renteria - can he keep it up?
Oswalt - can he return to form?
K. Brown - will he stay healthy?

Out:
T. Percival
C. Jones

I had really high expectaions of Oswalt, but injury has wrecked his season so far. I'd love to keep him, but a stud SS is hard to come by.

[duckboy]

I would keep Renteria. He has the best shot of putting up the numbers again.

I wouldn't trust Kevin Brown to be healthy and successful for two straight years. Something bad is due to happen to him.

[elfudge35]

absolutely, keep Renteria, but I also think you need to keep Oswalt, if Roy is healthy, he'll be better than Halladay, that's my advice