Baseball Guru
12-01-2003, 10:07 AM
Ok, as most of you know, almost 2 years ago, Shawn and myself came up with our own HOF:
S&J HOF (http://www.addictsports.com/baseball/showthread.php?threadid=4402)
The only things we looked for were that the player is retired....So this list along with this site will hopefully keep growing....
We included players banned from MLB that deserve to be in...
These players include Pete Rose and Joe Jackson.....
The only definites that made our list were any pitcher that won 300, any hitter that had 3000 hits or 500 HR's....
Any player that was on the fence, we probably left out.....Most all we agreed on, some we did not....I gave a little, he gave a little...
All in all it was fun and challenging...
But now it is time for us to induct a new class......
Last year there were no inductions.....
This year however we now have a player in Roger Clemens who is now eligible as he is now retired..... (We are still waiting for Rickey Henderson to retire;) )
So far Shawn and I have agreed on Andre Dawson as a new member to our HOF along with Clemens....
What we want from you guys are other possible suggestions on who should gain entry to our HOF..
Take a look at our list and let us know who you think should be in and why.... Make your arguement a good one as we are hard on new members;)
Once you have made your post on your choices and why they should be in, then we can start the debate but keep in mind, the final say if that player makes it in will be by Shawn and myself...
This should be fun so let the debates begin!!!!
BTW, we will keep this open for the whole month of December and have the inductions sometime the 2nd week of January....
S&J HOF (http://www.addictsports.com/baseball/showthread.php?threadid=4402)
The only things we looked for were that the player is retired....So this list along with this site will hopefully keep growing....
We included players banned from MLB that deserve to be in...
These players include Pete Rose and Joe Jackson.....
The only definites that made our list were any pitcher that won 300, any hitter that had 3000 hits or 500 HR's....
Any player that was on the fence, we probably left out.....Most all we agreed on, some we did not....I gave a little, he gave a little...
All in all it was fun and challenging...
But now it is time for us to induct a new class......
Last year there were no inductions.....
This year however we now have a player in Roger Clemens who is now eligible as he is now retired..... (We are still waiting for Rickey Henderson to retire;) )
So far Shawn and I have agreed on Andre Dawson as a new member to our HOF along with Clemens....
What we want from you guys are other possible suggestions on who should gain entry to our HOF..
Take a look at our list and let us know who you think should be in and why.... Make your arguement a good one as we are hard on new members;)
Once you have made your post on your choices and why they should be in, then we can start the debate but keep in mind, the final say if that player makes it in will be by Shawn and myself...
This should be fun so let the debates begin!!!!
BTW, we will keep this open for the whole month of December and have the inductions sometime the 2nd week of January....