What Do We Have In Common?

[Toy Cannon]

What do these players have in common?

Minnie Minoso
Jim Finigan
Frank Malzone
Buck Rodgers
Del Unser
Roy Foster
Rich Gedman
James Baldwin

[Yellow Dog]

Did they all finish second in the Rookie of the Year voting?

[Toy Cannon]

Yes they did, but I need a little more.