Panzram
06-24-2004, 04:09 AM
Callups: Travis Smith, Dewon Brazelton, Xavier Nady. . .
by Matt Watson
Our weekly look at players called up to the majors (for the first time this season) in the past seven days.
Travis Smith, RHP, Atl
Smith posted a solid 4-1 record and 2.49 ERA over nine starts (50.2 IP) with Triple-A Richmond before his big league promotion last week. He started twice and pitched well (3.46 ERA, 0.92 WHIP) in place of the injured Horacio Ramirez, but probably won't stick around if Ramirez is able to return this week as expected. At 31, Smith is a minor league journeyman and most definitely not a prospect. Feel free to pass on him without regret.
Joe Valentine, RHP, Cin
Valentine is considered by most to be a possible future closer or setup man, but the Reds asked him to try his hand at starting this year. It's been a disaster: he posted a 6.21 ERA over nine starts (37.2 IP) at Triple-A Louisville, and gave up three runs off five walks and two hits in just one inning during a spot start with the Reds. He had no business being asked to make a big league start in the first place, so go ahead and ignore him. Besides, Valentine was covering Paul Wilson's spot in the rotation for one turn, and Wilson has already returned to action.
Tim Olson, UT, Ari
He was hitting .362 over 69 at-bats with Triple-A Tucson before he was called up, but that's about one hundred points better than his career minor league average. He's simply a utilityman that was called up to replace the injured Matt Kata. Don't expect much playing time, or production, in his time up.
Ben Howard, RHP, Fla
Once a prospect as a starter, Howard has been used exclusively out of the bullpen at Triple-A Albuquerque this year. He's posted a 3.41 ERA with 25 strikeouts and 17 walks over 29 innings. The Marlins recalled him to fill Josh Beckett's spot on the roster, though not his spot in the rotation. After a shaky first week (3 games, 5 ER, 2.2 IP), why gamble on him now?
Mark Corey, RHP, Pit
Corey has been dominant in relief at Triple-A Nashville this year, posting a 1.85 ERA with 22 strikeouts and six walks over 24.1 IP. He's collected 12 saves along the way, earning a promotion to pitch middle relief for the Buccos. At 30 years old, it's not fair to call Corey a "closer of the future," though he could work his way into a valuable setup role. Jose Mesa has apparently forgotten he's Jose Mesa, and as such has been a consistent ninth-inning fireman this year. Should his memory return, Corey might be an effective stopgap. That's pure speculation, though, and it should be safe to leave him on your free agent list until Mesa shows signs of falling apart.
Felipe Lopez, SS, Cin
Juan Castro's trip to the DL earned Lopez a roster spot, and Barry Larkin's sore abdominal muscles has earned him some playing time. Lopez was once a top shortstop prospect, but inconsistency with his glove and bat in the big leagues has punched his ticket to the minors the past two seasons. He was hitting .289 with seven homers and 34 RBI in 194 AB with Triple-A Louisville before his promotion, but his 2-for-18 first week in the big leagues looks all too familiar.
Chris George, LHP, KC
At first glance, George's 1-3 record at Triple-A Omaha this year may turn you off. Then you notice his 2.32 ERA over 31 IP and wonder if you should give him a second look. Take a third look and realize he's struck out 17 with 12 walks -- he still lacks the control to be an effective big league starter. That was evident in his first start of the year last week: though he allowed "only" three runs in 6.2 IP, he allowed seven hits, walked five, and struck out only one. Taking a chance on him could sabotage your fantasy staff.
Matt Treanor, C, Fla
Despite an impressive start at Triple-A Albuquerque (.280-6-31), Treanor is not worthy of a fantasy pickup. He was called up simply to provide depth with Ramon Castro on the DL and won't garner enough at-bats to really matter. He's already 28 years old, so he's hardly a prospect.
Xavier Nady, OF, SD
Now 25, Nady hasn't developed into the elite player that the Padres had expected. His start at Triple-A Portland (.314-3-16) would be respectable for a middle infielder, but he's supposed to be a power-hitting corner outfielder. Brian Buchanan's injury gave him a roster spot, and he might garner some at-bats as the DH when the Friars tour the AL in interleague play this week. Go ahead and take a chance on him if you're looking for short-term help, but temper your expectations from what they were a year or two ago.
Esteban German, UT, Oak
A second baseman by trade, German may see time at third base while helping cover the loss of Eric Chavez. Mark McLemore is slated to earn the majority of time there, but German is nice insurance given the condition of McLemore's knees. German's best attribute may be his speed, though Oakland's philosophy renders his stolen base contributions minimal. He was hitting .333 with one home run and 20 RBI in 33 games at Triple-A Sacramento before the promotion.
Hiram Bocachica, UT, Sea
It's been a long time, but Bocachica was once highly regarded as a shortstop prospect. He's shown very little in the big leagues, however, bringing a .216 BA over 333 AB into the season. He hit .299-7-21 with 12 steals in 107 AB with Triple-A Tacoma before his promotion, however, and he could factor into the left field job with Raul Ibanez on the DL. If you're short on steals and just want to fill a roster spot, take a chance on him. He's a low-risk option that could prove useful in the short-term.
Dewon Brazelton, RHP, TB
Still considered a top prospect, Brazelton is flirting with becoming a bust. He's been thoroughly ineffective in two big league stints and was merely average (4.71 ERA, 38 strikeouts, 15 walks, 49.2 IP) in 10 starts with Triple-A Durham this year. Already 24, Brazelton needs to show some positive results soon. On the other hand, he can't possibly be worse than Paul Abbott has been this year, so he should get ample opportunity to prove himself.
Jesus Colome, RHP, TB
Colome is living proof that dialing up 100 mph on the radar gun does not guarantee big league success. Control has always been his nemesis, and there was nothing about his minor league numbers (17 strikeouts, 16 walks, 30.2 IP) that suggests he's ready for consistent success. If anything, his declining strikeouts should be a sign to stay away.
Bob File, RHP, Tor
He allowed just 1 ER over 17.2 IP with Triple-A Syracuse before his promotion. That's too small of a sample size to get excited about, especially considering he's only struck out six batters while walking four. Yawn. Jason Frasor is still dominating hitters as the Jays pseudo-closer, so there's no reason to speculate on Toronto relievers like you did early in the season.
Yadier Molina, C, StL
Molina joined brothers Bengie and Jose in the big leagues when the Cards called him up to replace the injured Mike Matheny. He was hitting .310 with one home run and 14 RBI over 126 AB with Triple-A Memphis before his promotion. Considering the only other option the Cards have behind the plate right now is Cody McKay, Molina should see at least part-time action until Matheny returns. He's a fine defensive backstop but he has almost no power at all. Can he at least hit for average? It's tough to say -- he's only 22 years old and may be a bit overmatched right now. Don't expect much and you won't be disappointed.
Choo Freeman, OF, Col
He was hitting .294 with three home runs and 25 RBI over 180 AB when the Rockies recalled him to provide an extra bat off the bench. He has plenty of speed but isn't as successful as you'd like him to be stealing bases. He's simply an outfield reserve for the time being. Fantasy owners in keeper leagues might be intrigued by his potential, but the odds of him contributing in the short-term are slim.
Todd Linden, OF, SF
After giving up on the Jeffrey Hammonds experiment, the Giants recalled Linden from Triple-A Fresno. He hit .286-4-32 before the promotion, stealing four bases in seven attempts. He's a switch-hitter with a touch of power, though perhaps not enough to be a factor at SBC Park. Perhaps he sees a few at-bats when the Giants use the DH in AL ballparks, but otherwise he's simply a reserve outfielder. The Giants should have given him a full-time job instead of signing Michael Tucker in the offseason, but what's done is done and Tucker is playing well enough to not worry about job security.
Jeff Liefer, 3B/OF/1B, Mil
Liefer showed his potential when he hit 18 HR in just 254 AB in 2001, but he's showed very little since. After tearing things up at Triple-A Indianapolis (.341-11-44 over 179 AB), however, the Brewers found room on their 40-man roster to give him another crack at the big leagues. He can play the infield and outfield corners, and could see time as a DH as the Brew Crew head to the AL this week. If you need home runs and play in a deep NL-only league, you could do a lot worse than giving him a short audition.
Matt Hensley, RHP, Ana
With Troy Percival on the DL, Francisco Rodriguez will move into the closer role. That leaves a hole at the setup spot that the Halos hope to fill with Hensley. He posted a sparkling 1.57 ERA with 32 strikeouts and five walks over 28.2 IP with Triple-A Salt Lake before the promotion. Considering that effort came in a hitter-friendly league, he should be up for the task of facing big league hitters. He won't be in a position to get saves and likely won't pitch enough innings to even vulture wins, but if you're looking for a cheap low-ERA, low-WHIP guy to eat a few innings while picking up a few strikeouts, this could be your guy.
Edgar Gonzalez, RHP, Ari
The D'Backs gave their 21 year-old prospect a spot start in place of the demoted Casey Daigle. Gonzalez struggled (6 ER, 4 IP), which wasn't surprising given his results at Triple-A Tucson this year (5.63 ERA, 1.37 WHIP). He's a fine prospect, but may be sent down before his spot in the rotation comes up again. With the exception of those playing in keeper leagues, there's no reason to pay much attention to Gonzalez for the time being.
Brandon Villafuerte, RHP, Ari
Villafuerte posted a 2.64 ERA with 23 strikeouts and 10 walks in 30.2 IP with Triple-A Tucson before his promotion. While he won't reproduce those numbers with the D'Backs, he shouldn't stray too far from a 4.00 ERA -- quite possibly staying below it. Considered a possible closer as recent as last year, Villafuerte won't have a chance at that type of role right now, though you can't rule anything out for good given Jose Valverde's struggles with consistency. His current role doesn't have enough value to risk taking a chance on him, but keep him in the back of your head if you own Valverde.
Jon Leicester, RHP, Cubs
After posting a 4.01 ERA with 55 strikeouts and 34 walks in 11 starts (60.2) with Triple-A Iowa, Leicester was recalled over the weekend to provide bullpen depth when Joe Borowski landed on the DL. While he has some strikeout ability, he obviously has some control issues, as well. In a limited role such as middle relief, there's just not enough of a payoff to consider taking a chance on him. Perhaps things would be different were he to crack the starting rotation, but that's not where we are right now.
by Matt Watson
Our weekly look at players called up to the majors (for the first time this season) in the past seven days.
Travis Smith, RHP, Atl
Smith posted a solid 4-1 record and 2.49 ERA over nine starts (50.2 IP) with Triple-A Richmond before his big league promotion last week. He started twice and pitched well (3.46 ERA, 0.92 WHIP) in place of the injured Horacio Ramirez, but probably won't stick around if Ramirez is able to return this week as expected. At 31, Smith is a minor league journeyman and most definitely not a prospect. Feel free to pass on him without regret.
Joe Valentine, RHP, Cin
Valentine is considered by most to be a possible future closer or setup man, but the Reds asked him to try his hand at starting this year. It's been a disaster: he posted a 6.21 ERA over nine starts (37.2 IP) at Triple-A Louisville, and gave up three runs off five walks and two hits in just one inning during a spot start with the Reds. He had no business being asked to make a big league start in the first place, so go ahead and ignore him. Besides, Valentine was covering Paul Wilson's spot in the rotation for one turn, and Wilson has already returned to action.
Tim Olson, UT, Ari
He was hitting .362 over 69 at-bats with Triple-A Tucson before he was called up, but that's about one hundred points better than his career minor league average. He's simply a utilityman that was called up to replace the injured Matt Kata. Don't expect much playing time, or production, in his time up.
Ben Howard, RHP, Fla
Once a prospect as a starter, Howard has been used exclusively out of the bullpen at Triple-A Albuquerque this year. He's posted a 3.41 ERA with 25 strikeouts and 17 walks over 29 innings. The Marlins recalled him to fill Josh Beckett's spot on the roster, though not his spot in the rotation. After a shaky first week (3 games, 5 ER, 2.2 IP), why gamble on him now?
Mark Corey, RHP, Pit
Corey has been dominant in relief at Triple-A Nashville this year, posting a 1.85 ERA with 22 strikeouts and six walks over 24.1 IP. He's collected 12 saves along the way, earning a promotion to pitch middle relief for the Buccos. At 30 years old, it's not fair to call Corey a "closer of the future," though he could work his way into a valuable setup role. Jose Mesa has apparently forgotten he's Jose Mesa, and as such has been a consistent ninth-inning fireman this year. Should his memory return, Corey might be an effective stopgap. That's pure speculation, though, and it should be safe to leave him on your free agent list until Mesa shows signs of falling apart.
Felipe Lopez, SS, Cin
Juan Castro's trip to the DL earned Lopez a roster spot, and Barry Larkin's sore abdominal muscles has earned him some playing time. Lopez was once a top shortstop prospect, but inconsistency with his glove and bat in the big leagues has punched his ticket to the minors the past two seasons. He was hitting .289 with seven homers and 34 RBI in 194 AB with Triple-A Louisville before his promotion, but his 2-for-18 first week in the big leagues looks all too familiar.
Chris George, LHP, KC
At first glance, George's 1-3 record at Triple-A Omaha this year may turn you off. Then you notice his 2.32 ERA over 31 IP and wonder if you should give him a second look. Take a third look and realize he's struck out 17 with 12 walks -- he still lacks the control to be an effective big league starter. That was evident in his first start of the year last week: though he allowed "only" three runs in 6.2 IP, he allowed seven hits, walked five, and struck out only one. Taking a chance on him could sabotage your fantasy staff.
Matt Treanor, C, Fla
Despite an impressive start at Triple-A Albuquerque (.280-6-31), Treanor is not worthy of a fantasy pickup. He was called up simply to provide depth with Ramon Castro on the DL and won't garner enough at-bats to really matter. He's already 28 years old, so he's hardly a prospect.
Xavier Nady, OF, SD
Now 25, Nady hasn't developed into the elite player that the Padres had expected. His start at Triple-A Portland (.314-3-16) would be respectable for a middle infielder, but he's supposed to be a power-hitting corner outfielder. Brian Buchanan's injury gave him a roster spot, and he might garner some at-bats as the DH when the Friars tour the AL in interleague play this week. Go ahead and take a chance on him if you're looking for short-term help, but temper your expectations from what they were a year or two ago.
Esteban German, UT, Oak
A second baseman by trade, German may see time at third base while helping cover the loss of Eric Chavez. Mark McLemore is slated to earn the majority of time there, but German is nice insurance given the condition of McLemore's knees. German's best attribute may be his speed, though Oakland's philosophy renders his stolen base contributions minimal. He was hitting .333 with one home run and 20 RBI in 33 games at Triple-A Sacramento before the promotion.
Hiram Bocachica, UT, Sea
It's been a long time, but Bocachica was once highly regarded as a shortstop prospect. He's shown very little in the big leagues, however, bringing a .216 BA over 333 AB into the season. He hit .299-7-21 with 12 steals in 107 AB with Triple-A Tacoma before his promotion, however, and he could factor into the left field job with Raul Ibanez on the DL. If you're short on steals and just want to fill a roster spot, take a chance on him. He's a low-risk option that could prove useful in the short-term.
Dewon Brazelton, RHP, TB
Still considered a top prospect, Brazelton is flirting with becoming a bust. He's been thoroughly ineffective in two big league stints and was merely average (4.71 ERA, 38 strikeouts, 15 walks, 49.2 IP) in 10 starts with Triple-A Durham this year. Already 24, Brazelton needs to show some positive results soon. On the other hand, he can't possibly be worse than Paul Abbott has been this year, so he should get ample opportunity to prove himself.
Jesus Colome, RHP, TB
Colome is living proof that dialing up 100 mph on the radar gun does not guarantee big league success. Control has always been his nemesis, and there was nothing about his minor league numbers (17 strikeouts, 16 walks, 30.2 IP) that suggests he's ready for consistent success. If anything, his declining strikeouts should be a sign to stay away.
Bob File, RHP, Tor
He allowed just 1 ER over 17.2 IP with Triple-A Syracuse before his promotion. That's too small of a sample size to get excited about, especially considering he's only struck out six batters while walking four. Yawn. Jason Frasor is still dominating hitters as the Jays pseudo-closer, so there's no reason to speculate on Toronto relievers like you did early in the season.
Yadier Molina, C, StL
Molina joined brothers Bengie and Jose in the big leagues when the Cards called him up to replace the injured Mike Matheny. He was hitting .310 with one home run and 14 RBI over 126 AB with Triple-A Memphis before his promotion. Considering the only other option the Cards have behind the plate right now is Cody McKay, Molina should see at least part-time action until Matheny returns. He's a fine defensive backstop but he has almost no power at all. Can he at least hit for average? It's tough to say -- he's only 22 years old and may be a bit overmatched right now. Don't expect much and you won't be disappointed.
Choo Freeman, OF, Col
He was hitting .294 with three home runs and 25 RBI over 180 AB when the Rockies recalled him to provide an extra bat off the bench. He has plenty of speed but isn't as successful as you'd like him to be stealing bases. He's simply an outfield reserve for the time being. Fantasy owners in keeper leagues might be intrigued by his potential, but the odds of him contributing in the short-term are slim.
Todd Linden, OF, SF
After giving up on the Jeffrey Hammonds experiment, the Giants recalled Linden from Triple-A Fresno. He hit .286-4-32 before the promotion, stealing four bases in seven attempts. He's a switch-hitter with a touch of power, though perhaps not enough to be a factor at SBC Park. Perhaps he sees a few at-bats when the Giants use the DH in AL ballparks, but otherwise he's simply a reserve outfielder. The Giants should have given him a full-time job instead of signing Michael Tucker in the offseason, but what's done is done and Tucker is playing well enough to not worry about job security.
Jeff Liefer, 3B/OF/1B, Mil
Liefer showed his potential when he hit 18 HR in just 254 AB in 2001, but he's showed very little since. After tearing things up at Triple-A Indianapolis (.341-11-44 over 179 AB), however, the Brewers found room on their 40-man roster to give him another crack at the big leagues. He can play the infield and outfield corners, and could see time as a DH as the Brew Crew head to the AL this week. If you need home runs and play in a deep NL-only league, you could do a lot worse than giving him a short audition.
Matt Hensley, RHP, Ana
With Troy Percival on the DL, Francisco Rodriguez will move into the closer role. That leaves a hole at the setup spot that the Halos hope to fill with Hensley. He posted a sparkling 1.57 ERA with 32 strikeouts and five walks over 28.2 IP with Triple-A Salt Lake before the promotion. Considering that effort came in a hitter-friendly league, he should be up for the task of facing big league hitters. He won't be in a position to get saves and likely won't pitch enough innings to even vulture wins, but if you're looking for a cheap low-ERA, low-WHIP guy to eat a few innings while picking up a few strikeouts, this could be your guy.
Edgar Gonzalez, RHP, Ari
The D'Backs gave their 21 year-old prospect a spot start in place of the demoted Casey Daigle. Gonzalez struggled (6 ER, 4 IP), which wasn't surprising given his results at Triple-A Tucson this year (5.63 ERA, 1.37 WHIP). He's a fine prospect, but may be sent down before his spot in the rotation comes up again. With the exception of those playing in keeper leagues, there's no reason to pay much attention to Gonzalez for the time being.
Brandon Villafuerte, RHP, Ari
Villafuerte posted a 2.64 ERA with 23 strikeouts and 10 walks in 30.2 IP with Triple-A Tucson before his promotion. While he won't reproduce those numbers with the D'Backs, he shouldn't stray too far from a 4.00 ERA -- quite possibly staying below it. Considered a possible closer as recent as last year, Villafuerte won't have a chance at that type of role right now, though you can't rule anything out for good given Jose Valverde's struggles with consistency. His current role doesn't have enough value to risk taking a chance on him, but keep him in the back of your head if you own Valverde.
Jon Leicester, RHP, Cubs
After posting a 4.01 ERA with 55 strikeouts and 34 walks in 11 starts (60.2) with Triple-A Iowa, Leicester was recalled over the weekend to provide bullpen depth when Joe Borowski landed on the DL. While he has some strikeout ability, he obviously has some control issues, as well. In a limited role such as middle relief, there's just not enough of a payoff to consider taking a chance on him. Perhaps things would be different were he to crack the starting rotation, but that's not where we are right now.