Fred Taylor not that good?

[TRG]

I read at www.rotogenius.com that everyone (the "experts") are overrating Fred Taylor. Do you think that's true? Cause I have to choose between him and Onterrio Smith.

[renuszm]

After today, I dont think I will ever be going to rotogenius.

Just thought I would mention, that if anything, Fred Taylor is underrated.

[Thedatch]

After today, I dont think I will ever be going to rotogenius.

Just thought I would mention, that if anything, Fred Taylor is underrated.

:laff: seriously! 144 yards? haha rotogenius

[ims0phat]

i dont know that hes UNDERRATED, lets not get ahead of ourselves for one game against one of the worst rushing defenses in the NFL. theres no question that fred taylor is a good player, but some of his efforts so far this year have been subpar, in fact this is by far his best this year. id have to say that the experts probably have him rated correctly. in a choice between him and onterrio smith, id probably stick with him until its completely clear the situation in minnesota.

[PopTop]

Figures! The one week I finally take him out of my lineup, he goes off :hmm: Both he and the team are inconsistent.


.

[renuszm]

i dont know that hes UNDERRATED, lets not get ahead of ourselves for one game against one of the worst rushing defenses in the NFL. theres no question that fred taylor is a good player, but some of his efforts so far this year have been subpar, in fact this is by far his best this year. id have to say that the experts probably have him rated correctly. in a choice between him and onterrio smith, id probably stick with him until its completely clear the situation in minnesota.
Yeah but so many people were concerned about injuries with him in years past, and they didnt realize he had 1500+ yards. last year.

[ims0phat]

definitely there are some idiots out there. but the experts know his place. that whole thing about "injury prone' is a bunch of crap to me. hes been injury free the past few years putting up numbers each year.