w/ bulger out, who to start

[ims0phat]

with marc bulger out yet another week, i have the options of david carr or patrick ramsey. carr is facing a tough chicago defense while ramsey is facing the joke of the 49ers. (being a redskins fan, i try not to be biased but this has to mean a decent game for ramsey at least) advice? in another issue, i have RB's portis, jamal lewis, fred taylor, and thomas jones, and chester taylor who def wont play for me this week. portis is in for sure, but now should i even consider jamal lewis against the weak defense of the colts even though he'll only take about 2/3 of the snaps? im thinking to go with fred taylor against a weak defense in green bay.

[Panzram]

I'd say Carr just because Ramsey sucks but you might want to get other opinions on that.

[PopTop]

I think it's a coin flip. I really haven't seen Ramsey this year other than in highlights. Carr just doesn't seem to bright out there a lot of times, and ditto times three for whoever calls the plays for the Houston Cows. I think I'd take a gamble on Ramsey. At least he seems to have a better chance to have a better day than Carr.


Defense Question: It's our league semi finals this week, and my third trip to the semi's in 5 years. My lineup is pretty easy to pick except for the fact I'm struggling with my defense this time ---

Denver @ Kansas City
Washington @ San Francisco
Carolina @ Atlanta

I've been using the Denver D most of the time this season. But I'm really leaning towards the Redskins this week on the road against the 49ers. Any thoughts or ideas on that are greatly appreciated.

[ims0phat]

as a redskins fan, i can't say that i'm not biased but i know this for a fact, the redskins defense is simply one of the best in the league. they are either 2 or 3 overall im pretty sure. dont let their team's record fool you, their defense is top notch. id go with them. also koz, im curious y u think ramsey "sucks"? last year was mostly not his fault it was a terrible o-line and this year he has done well in the last few games since finally getting the job from brunell.

[Panzram]

I'm looking at Ramsey's TD/INT ratio.

[645]

Carr is the better one of the two but he isn't a great pick.

I would take a look at the Available QB's. If Boller,Collins,Volek or Chandler are not tolken yet. Any of them may be a better play this week.

[>TC<]

Ramsey might be a better bet. The 49ers are shakey on D.

The Redskins are a better play on D. KC vs. Den could be a shootout.

TC

[ims0phat]

oh come on 645, chandler a better start than carr?? ill be surprised of chandler didnt get a concussion

[ims0phat]

ps i went w/ carr and it worked out ok