PDA

View Full Version : Who Goes to the All-Star Game?

Chisox73
06-12-2005, 06:10 PM
Simple question here foor you guys and gals out there.

Which White Sox player or players do you think should go to the All-Star Game in Detroit? Discuss.
Timberwolf
06-12-2005, 06:21 PM
Buherle, Garland, and Podesneik.

I think White Sox get 3 All-Stars and the Twins get 3 All-Stars each with the rest filled with Red Sox players and team representations. At least, we will be spared with Yankees players in the ASG. If you ask me, no Yankee deserve to be in the ASG.
Chisox73
06-12-2005, 06:28 PM
At least we won't have to see Joe Torre this year stack his team with 8 or 9 Yankees.

I wouldn't mind seeing Ozzie Guillen go in as a coach. :thumbsup:
Vince10984
06-12-2005, 11:44 PM
Buherle, Garland, and Podesneik.

I think White Sox get 3 All-Stars and the Twins get 3 All-Stars each with the rest filled with Red Sox players and team representations. At least, we will be spared with Yankees players in the ASG. If you ask me, no Yankee deserve to be in the ASG.
A-Rod does.
Timberwolf
06-13-2005, 12:17 AM
Vince: Rodriguez hasn't done it for me. I will give you Rivera though.

Francona better not do the same. Look I understand that the manager has to pick his own guys on his own team or risking losing them, but there has to be a limit. Torre goes way overboard. 5 guys should be the max that should be selected on the team and that's it.
Vince10984
06-14-2005, 02:08 PM
Rodriguez hasn't done it for you??

Hes batting .323, with 19 HR, 56 RBI, 48 R, with 6 SB

If that's not enough to get into the All-Star game, I dont know what is.
Timberwolf
06-14-2005, 03:12 PM
He should hit 30 HRs by now. Bonds would have put better numbers than that if he was healthy.

My standards on Pay-Rod is pretty high.
Thedatch
06-14-2005, 03:21 PM
He should hit 30 HRs by now. Bonds would have put better numbers than that if he was healthy.

My standards on Pay-Rod is pretty high.

doesnt matter how high your standards are... If I had really low standards for someone who was hitting .150, that still doesnt mean he'd make the all star team in my book. The dude is leading the AL in most offensive catagories...give me a break!
Royce
06-14-2005, 03:23 PM
He should hit 30 HRs by now. Bonds would have put better numbers than that if he was healthy.

My standards on Pay-Rod is pretty high.



No body has more then 17 homers besides him. And apparently Tino and A-Rod are automatically going b/c they lead in votes at the positions. Sheffield deserves to go, and Jeter deserves to go. Tino has done shit all year except for that one streak, otherwise he'd have terrible #'s. Posada is also one of the top 5 AL catchers.