PDA

View Full Version : Apple's The Best ...but Chicago & Houston on list of Top 10 sports towns


GaryMrMets
10-24-2005, 12:58 PM
Apple's The Best
...but Chicago & Houston on list of Top 10 sports towns

By Mike Vaccaro

Chicago - Say what you want about the teams battling for the World Series. Talk about their long and proud dance with futility as much as you'd like - and you could spend weeks and weeks talking about thay, and about the mathematical improbabilitiy that a team that's 0-for-43 can get paired with a team that's 0-for-88.

Someone has to end that streak. Astros. White Sox. One of them is going to be champion of baseball sometime soon. The idea of seeing "2005 World Series Champions" on any shirt containing the Sox logo or the Astro star is completely shocking.

But seeing Houston and Chicago in a big sporting event?

That makes perfect sense. Because as sports towns they are among the best in the United States of America. Spend some time among the locals, spend some time in their stadiums, and you'll understsnd why. So in honor of Big Shoulders battling Big Hair for the Big Trophy, here's one man's pick for the 10 best sports towns in America. Gentlemen (and ladies), start your e-mail replies:

1. New York
Ok, call this a parochial pick, call me a homer, call me whatever you like. But anyone who thinks New York isn't in a class by itself in this subject has obviously never spent much time watching sports in New York. No city on earth hosts a big event better, and in so many places: Yankee Stadium in the fall, Madison Square Garden in the spring, the Meadowlands in the winter for a football playoff game. Other cities can recite longer sellout streaks, or more successful franchises, or more fans who choose to paint their faces and run around with their shirts off in sub-zero weather. That's fine. Other cities know how to be sports cities. Only New York knows how to be the best sports city.

2. Boston
You know how they usually build sets for historical movies to 7/8th scaleto the originals? That's what Boston is to New York. In many ways, Boston fans have every bit the passion, intensity and knowledge of their New York counterparts; it's just a little bit smaller town, with a couple fewer teams, and a resulting number of fewer fans. That said, an afternoon Gillette Stadium or an evening at Fenway Park is as splendid an experience as there is in sports, even if you don't have a rooting interest for the home team. And Boston does get the edge in the sports-bar department - you can get just as much a feel at a favored saloon as you can at Fenway, Fleet, or Gillette.

3. St. Louis
Granted St. Louis makes it this high based almost solely on the devotion the locals have for the baseball Cardinals, even though the Rams' run the past few years has turned the dome into an ear bleeding experience most Sundays. But the Cardinals rule St. Louis, and St. Louis is consumed with the Cardinals, and it's a remarkable thing to watch grown men and women in a pro town holding pep rallies before big baseball series.

4. Philadelphia
We will try to make it through an entire paragraph about Philly sports without talking about how the locals once booed Santa Claus (ah, well, maybe next time). Nowhere do you find stadiums and arenas packedto the rafters with so many amateur columnists and talk-radio commentators. The line between being revered and reviled is thinner here than anywhere else on earth.

5. Chicago
All you need to know about how good a sports town Chicago is is this: back when Michael Jordan ruled the world, it still took the Bulls a few years to approach the devotion afforded the Bears or the baseball teams. And let's face it: to support two ballclubs like the Sox and the Cubs, who have weilded heartbreak like a machetefor so many years, earns you an automatic spot on my list such as this one. Easy.

6. Cleveland
Like St. Louis, it's a town that qualifies for the list, despite having teams in three of the four main food groups. And although LeBron James has brought a measure of cache back to the Cavaliers, it's really just a two team-team town. And, well, the Indians have packed so much heartache during their 57-year run without a title. But the Browns - this incarnation, all of them - set this city's mood and perpetuate its status. Fans everywhere live and die with their teams in a figurative sense. In Cleveland, it's literal.

7. Denver
The way Denver fans have reacted and respondedto the Broncos for the last 30 years, and to the Avalanche for the last 10, makes you wonder just how cool a fantasyland Coors Field could be if the Rockies could ever stop slipping on banana peels there. There has never been a more intimidating sound than when 70,000 people started banging their feet against the aluminum stands at old Mile High Stadium.

8. Houston
The Astrodome looks like a quaint relic from a Stanley Kubrick movie now, but back in the day it was the first stadium that inspired people to take tours of the place even without a game to see. Minute Maid Park is the best home field in baseball now, and we will assume Reliant Stadium will become the same way if the Texans ever decide to play varsity football.

9. Kansas City
Ask the Jets how much fun it is to play at Arrowhead Stadium when it's covered in red. And this is still a wonderful baseball town when the baseball team isn't trying to get by on a 76-cent payroll.

10. Pittsburgh
And if Sidney Crosby can actually make the Penguins relevant again, watch out, because the Steel City has two of the best new stadiums of any constructed during the recent building boom.

(Mike Vaccaro's e-mail address is WriteBackVac@aol.com. His Yankees - Red Sox book, "Emperors and Idiots," is available in bookstores everywhere).

racinghoss
10-24-2005, 01:10 PM
I agree with 9 of the 10, although I would change the order somewhat. Good list and great thinking. However, Houston? I am glad they are in the WS (although I hope they lose), but I have never considered Houston a big sports town. Granted, I have not spent much time there, but Houston? This years WS is the first time in a long time I have seen a Houston team really doing well. Granted, they have been pretty good for a couple years now, but that is really it. Thier ballpark is nice.

Replace Houston with Washington DC, and put Chicago on top (or at least 2nd or 3rd) and the list is complete, IMHO.

BayStateBabe
10-24-2005, 01:27 PM
Chicago should be #3. Otherwise the only other problem I have with the list is Minute Maid Park being the best home field. I've been there. Not impressed.

PissedPrincess
10-24-2005, 02:06 PM
Gimmee a break. Half of New Yorkers don't even know what professional sports are. The other half roots for whoever is good. New York is the biggest front-running town of all, because it has so many teams.

I'd take half the cities on that list over NY.

Timberwolf
10-24-2005, 07:58 PM
You said it, PP.

I am glad you posted this, Gary. I had lot to say and I will email the same thing to Mike Vaccaro, who I talk a lot on AIM and on emails.

New York is the most overrated sports town in America. I have lived in this area for my entire life so I have a great grasp on this. New York is a good sports town when they are winning, but when they are losing, those knowledgable NY sports fans are never there. Look at Shea Stadium. That place has been a ghost town during the Art Howe and Dallas Green era. Yankee Stadium could not draw anyone in the eighties. Madison Square Garden has been dead the last few years with the ineptcy of the Rangers and Knicks. To me, that's not what you call a great sports town. A great sports town to me is fans who stood there through thick and thing. Oh and NY lose points with me on football. Giants and Jets play at East Rutherford, NJ not in NY. If NY is that great of a sports town, why can't they build their own football stadium.

As much as I hate Boston sports fans, I am not ashamed to admit Boston is the best sports town in America. Boston fans are what you call loyal. Bruins and the Celtics drew well when their teams stunk. When the Red Sox stunk during the Butch Hobson years, they still drew well at Fenway which is something Yankees fans can't even say. Patriots fans were huge during the Rod Rust and Dick MacPherson years. Boston College draws well unlike St. John's through win or losses.

Chicago is the second best sports city in America.

New York comes seventh in my list.

My best sports cities:
1) Boston
2) Chicago
3) Philly
4) St. Louis
5) Detroit
6) Dallas
7) New York
8) Pittsburgh
9) Seattle
10) Minneapolis-St. Paul

You get the feeling Mike is being a homer or the fact that his boss is telling him to write this because knowing Mike, he could not possibly believe it. If you can infer from his comments, I think he means Boston is the best sports town. His comment about how NY fields the best sports event means nothing since any sports city can field a great sports event if their team is a championship game.