Are Hermida or Francoeur worth keeping?

[daverich_1861]

Which of these guys is worth keeping? We use basic 5x5 scoring.

I would like to get a solid #2 SP to go with carpenter but not sure who i could get if i tried to trade one of them. Or should i keep another bat and forget these two guys?



Here is my roster (* keeper)

C M. Lieberthal (Phi - C)
1B D. Lee (ChC - 1B)*
2B T. Graffanino (Bos - 1B,2B,3B)
3B M. Ensberg (Hou - 3B)*
SS R. Furcal (Atl - SS)*
OF C. Jones (Atl - 3B,OF)*
OF C. Beltrán (NYM - OF)*
OF C. Floyd (NYM - OF)
Util J. Dye (CWS - OF)
Util J. Giambi (NYY - 1B)
BN T. Walker (ChC - 2B)
BN J. Francoeur (Atl - OF)
BN A. Rowand (CWS - OF)
BN J. Hermida (Fla - OF)
DL S. SosaDL (Bal - OF)
SP C. Carpenter (StL - SP)*
SP Ol. Pérez (Pit - SP)
RP J. Nathan (Min - RP)*
RP E. Guardado (Sea - RP)
P F. Rodney (Det - RP)
P M. Mussina (NYY - SP)
P D. Davis (Mil - SP)
BN B. Arroyo (Bos - SP)
BN D. Cabrera (Bal - SP)
BN K. Foulke (Bos - RP)
BN C. Young (Tex - SP)

[Panzram]

I'd keep Francoeur over Hermida. In my opinion, Jeremy is still young and might take a year or two before he has a real impact.

[PopTop]

Damn! How many keepers do you get to keep?

[daverich_1861]

We keep eight players


I know i will keep these six for sure

Lee
Furcal
Ensberg
Beltran
Carpenter
Nathan


I am on the fence with Chipper.